Posts Tagged ‘Raj Patel’

Raj Patel is not a messiah

Tuesday, April 13th, 2010

Raj Patel is the best-selling author of Stuffed and starved: markets, power and the hidden battle for the world food system (originally published in 2007), and The value of nothing: how to reshape market society and redefine democracy (2009).   Some people think he is some kind of messiah: he denies it.

In an article in the Guardian on Monday, Patel took the opportunity to write about his situation:

In part, I suspect the reason the story isn’t going away – the New York Times just ran a followup – is because it fits a narrative in which we’re steeped from birth. From the Bible to Knight Rider to The Matrix, the story’s the same: in crappy times, a single person will emerge to make all the difference and turn everything around. Although it makes for great viewing, it makes for a bad society. Ultimately, tales about messiahs are bedtime stories steeped in power. They’re debilitating soporifics, inducements to be passive as we wait for social change because, some day, our prince will come.

Why wait, though? If the world is to transform, faith in politicians offering hope and change is a recipe for disappointment. Ask almost anyone who voted for Obama. Change happens through millions of acts of rebellion and mutual aid, not through faith in one great leader. What’s depressing about this whole Maitreya thing is that it is a sign that we’ve given up on ourselves, that we need to depend on The One rather than finding the means to fix our own problems directly.

There’s a lot there with which Incredulity agrees.  But I want to be picky.  The idea that religious beliefs act to discourage activism is a familiar bit of rhetoric – I’ve used the “get up off your knees” line myself – but is it true?  There are plenty of religious people whose beliefs have inspired their progressive radicalism or reformism, and of course reactionary activism too. 

How many people abstain from political engagement because they think a messiah is on the way?  Probably not that many: the problem is the opposite one of conservative messiah-believers using their collective political muscle to get their own way.  If we think that because they spend a lot of time praying they therefore don’t have time for doing stuff, we run the risk of complacency.

I’ll end with a line or two from the end of Patel’s article, with which I can wholeheartedly agree:

This… is the world I’m keen to live in: one without princes but with billions of world teachers, in which we live under neither God nor Master. It’s a recipe for change that makes for poor storytelling but great politics.

Posted by: Dan @ Incredulity Services